Pensions Recruitment: What should I look for in a pensions recruiter?

Martin Wigfield • April 25, 2024

Pensions Recruitment: What should I look for in a pensions recruiter?

Should you apply directly to a business or is using a pensions recruiter a better option?

With there being many different routes to securing a role, who is best to go a with? An internal recruiter (who works for a specific company) or external pensions recruiter?


In our experience, we have seen good and bad on both sides of the fence. This blog covers the 4 things I would look for in a recruiter regardless of approach. 


Understanding:


At the heart of any fruitful recruiter-candidate relationship lies understanding. It's not just about ticking boxes but delving deeper into your aspirations, motivations, and the essence of what you seek in your next career move. A pensions recruiter who invests time in comprehending your unique journey is more likely to align opportunities with your long-term goals.


Be honest (even when it's bad news)


Transparency is the cornerstone of trust.


Exceptional pensions recruiters uphold honesty, even when it means delivering unwelcome news. They don't shy away from discussing potential mismatches between you and a role or being forthright about historical bonus structures and company turnover rates.


Genuine conversations pave the way for informed decisions. If you are worried they aren't forthcoming with this type of information, don't shy away from asking the questions.


Are they credible?


Evaluating a recruiter's credibility is crucial.


Do their perspectives align with your industry understanding? Are they familiar with the intricacies of pensions recruitment and the current hiring trends?


While experience is essential, the depth of their expertise matters just as much. Whether it's their grasp of hiring managers' preferences or their nuanced understanding of pensions, credibility lays the foundation for a successful partnership.


How are they paid?


This is a side of the pensions recruitment industry I don't hear discussed that often however, delving into the intricacies of how recruiters are compensated provides valuable insights into their motivations and priorities, shaping the nature of your collaboration.


Internal Recruiters: These professionals provide an invaluable insider's perspective as they should be immersed within the company they represent. However, their focus may lean more towards their organisation's needs, potentially limiting their broader pensions market insight compared to external recruiters.


No Win No Fee Recruiters: Offering a wide spectrum of opportunities, these recruiters operate under a unique compensation model where their earnings hinge on successful placements. While this can present a diverse range of options for candidates, it's essential to recognise that their incentives might be skewed towards encouraging job transitions rather than considering the best fit for your career goals.


Retained Recruiters:  Retained recruiters receive an upfront portion of their fee to conduct the search, allowing them to focus on understanding your needs and goals. Their priority is filling the position, leveraging their in-depth knowledge of the business, role, and recruitment process. Similar to no win no fee recruiters, a significant portion (around 30% - 50%) of their pay is contingent upon successfully filling the retained position.


Partnership Recruiters: Blending elements of both internal and retained models, partnership recruiters offer a balance between insider knowledge and dedicated service. While they may not cover the entire market, they collaborate closely with select firms, enabling them to provide tailored guidance and across a broad selection of roles. Their compensation typically revolves around a monthly payment structure, fostering sustained engagement and ensuring their commitment to your success extends beyond immediate placements.


So who which recruiter do I go with?


Here at Zatori, we deploy the partnership model 90% of the time. We believe it provides a great blend between the internal and external models however, there really is no one size fits all answer to this.


The right recruiter is the one who resonates with your needs and preferences. Don't hesitate to explore different options and put recruiters to the test. Your journey deserves a partner who not only understands but also champions you.


If you'd like to see how we can drive forward your pensions career, book a call below!


Martin

Co-Founder


Martin has been advising businesses in talent acquisition and retention for over a decade. Discuss how you he can help you elevate your strategy, book a call or contact him at martin.wigfield@zatori-consulting.co.uk

Book a call
By Martin Wigfield June 17, 2025
One thing has become crystal clear: pensions recruitment isn’t just a challenge, it’s a constant strain.
By Martin Wigfield May 8, 2025
At Zatori Consulting, we are often asked what our core activity is and the answer is simple, we exist to help businesses build brilliant teams in the pensions and wealth management sectors through strategic, targeted recruitment and talent acquisition. In a recent video , our founder Martin Wigfield summed up our ethos perfectly: “Leaders create plans – but people power them.” This statement underpins everything we do. In both pensions recruitment and wealth management recruitment , ambitious strategies fall flat without the right people to drive them forward. All too often, organisations put together detailed growth or transformation plans, only to overlook the talent strategy needed to bring those plans to life. That’s where Zatori steps in.
By Martin Wigfield March 20, 2025
I n-house pensions teams tell us they struggle to access the right talent through the dated pensions recruitment agency model who take pensions jobs to market with mixed results. We created a new way for UK pension funds to access top pensions talent.
By Martin Wigfield February 21, 2025
We help firms ensure they are equipped to tackle the world of pensions recruitment allowing them to set strategies that work, make better hiring decisions and retain talent for longer.
By Martin Wigfield January 29, 2025
Navigating the challenges of in-house pensions recruitment in 2025 to ensure you can deal with the challenges of today and be ready for the likes of pension dashboard down the track.
By Martin Wigfield January 9, 2025
Trustees, Pension Managers and In-House Teams have been battling challenges around pension fund recruitment as a result of legislative changes for year. We take time to explore the options you have to solve them.
By Martin Wigfield January 6, 2025
Co-Founder Martin Wigfield Takes Full Ownership of Zatori as Investors Kathy Harmer and Adrian Dalby Successfully Exit the Business
By Martin Wigfield July 3, 2024
Wealth Management Recruiters can fall into the trap of thinking it's all about finding people for roles. Here is why this narrow mindset is a mistake when it comes to delivering first class pensions recruitment!
By Martin Wigfield July 3, 2024
Pensions Recruiters can fall into the trap of thinking it's all about finding people for roles. Here is why this narrow mindset is a mistake when it comes to delivering first class pensions recruitment!
By Martin Wigfield May 31, 2024
Securing niche talent in highly competitive market places is hard. Buck, A Gallagher company, decided they needed a competitive advantage when it came to attracting the best talent to join them. They set us a very simple task, hire 40 high quality, experienced individuals in a niche market over a 2 year period. Working alongside a newly recruited internal recruitment team, we partnered with Buck on their most difficult assignments (there was no low hanging fruit). By engaging us, we were able to dedicate the time they and the assignments needed to gear them for success. This involved: Strategy: Understanding what the current strategy was and using our insights and data analytics to help them optimise their talent strategy Search: We created a whole new suite of recruitment assets that bought to life their employee value proposition and used them to take an evidence based approach to applicant attraction. Selection: Because we had been involved from the beginning, we knew the teams and their requirements inside out. It meant our vet was thorough and against the specific role requirements. This free's up interview time to be spent on in depth technical assessment as well as a two way 'fit' discussion. Onboarding: We worked closely with Buck and their new onboarding processes to ensure the candidate experience was a positive one. This included completing an aftercare discussion with all successful individuals at various stages throughout their first 6 months in the team. As a  result of recruiting through our talent subscription Buck went from not being able to attract the volumes they need to making the 40 hires in 18 months (not the 24 they ha d planned). This facilitated their growth allowing them to go and secure more new business faster, driving forward the growth of the practice to new levels.